Grange Mutual Casualty Company Insurance Review: Comprehensive Overview

🔹 Basic Company Overview
Key Aspect | Details |
Full Company Name | Grange Mutual Insurance Casualty Company |
Year Founded | 1935 |
Founders | Founded by Robert B. Black |
Headquartered Location | Columbus, Ohio, USA |
Company Mission Statement | “Grange Mutual aims to provide dependable and affordable insurance coverage to individuals and businesses while ensuring exceptional customer service.” |
Vision and Core Values | Vision: To be a trusted leader in the insurance industry by offering innovative and reliable coverage. Core Values: Integrity, transparency, customer-centricity. |
Parent Company | None (Independent) |
Subsidiaries | Grange Life Insurance Company, Grange Property & Casualty Insurance Company |
Number of Employees | Approximately 2,000 |
Revenue (latest available) | $1.8 billion (2021) |
Global or Regional Presence | Primarily regional in the U.S., specifically in Midwestern and Southeastern states |
Public or Private Company | Private |
Stock Market Symbol | Not publicly traded |
🔹 Company Reputation & Recognition
- Customer Satisfaction Ratings: Grange Mutual enjoys high customer satisfaction ratings. Customers consistently commend their affordable rates, professional service, and fast claims processing. However, some complain about premium increases over time.
- AM Best / Moody’s / S&P Ratings:
- AM Best: A (Excellent), reflecting strong financial health.
- Moody’s: Not rated
- S&P: Not rated
- AM Best: A (Excellent), reflecting strong financial health.
- Industry Awards and Recognitions: Recognized for excellent customer service in the insurance industry. Grange Mutual Insurance has earned several accolades for its financial stability and customer-focused approach.
- Trustpilot or Google Reviews Overview: On Trustpilot, Grange Mutual Insurance has a 4.5/5 rating, with customers highlighting timely responses and friendly staff. Some reviews mention concerns about policy renewal rates but generally describe positive experiences.
- BBB Rating (Better Business Bureau): A+ rating, reflecting trustworthy business practices and customer satisfaction.
- Notable Partnerships or Endorsements: Grange Mutual partners with local real estate agencies, auto dealerships, and mortgage brokers, providing comprehensive insurance solutions for both individuals and businesses.


🔹 Eligibility Criteria
- Who is Eligible:
- Individuals: Available to homeowners, renters, and vehicle owners.
- Groups/Businesses: Commercial property owners, business owners, and small to medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) looking for comprehensive coverage.
- Individuals: Available to homeowners, renters, and vehicle owners.
- Age Limitations: No specific age limits for policyholders; however, the age of the property or vehicle may affect eligibility for some types of coverage.
- State Availability: Available in Ohio, Michigan, Georgia, and other select states in the Midwest and Southeast U.S.
- Citizenship or Residency Requirements: Must be a U.S. citizen or legal resident.
- Minimum Health or Financial Conditions: No health restrictions; however, financial stability may be required for business insurance.
- Documents Required to Apply:
- Proof of property ownership (home, car, etc.)
- Personal identification
- Previous insurance details (if applicable)
- Business financials (for business insurance)
- Proof of property ownership (home, car, etc.)
🔹 Types of Insurance Offered
- Life Insurance: Grange Mutual Insurance offers life insurance, including term life and whole life policies, designed to help families cover expenses after a loved one’s passing.
- Auto Insurance: Available for personal vehicles, with options for liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage.
- Health Insurance: Not offered by Grange Mutual; they specialize in property and casualty insurance.
- Homeowners Insurance: Offers homeowners, renters, and condo insurance with customizable coverage for personal property, liability, and living expenses.
- Renters Insurance: Provides affordable renters insurance covering personal property, liability, and additional living expenses in case of a covered loss.
- Disability Insurance: Short-term and long-term disability insurance policies available for individuals.
- Long-term Care Insurance: Not specifically offered, but does provide coverage for medical-related incidents in homeowners policies.
- Travel Insurance: Not available through Grange Mutual.
- Business/Commercial Insurance: Comprehensive business coverage, including property, liability, and worker’s compensation insurance.
- Pet Insurance: Not available through Grange Mutual.
- Boat/Motorcycle/RV Insurance: Offers specialized insurance for motorcycles, boats, and RVs with coverage for damage, theft, and liability.
- Umbrella Insurance: Additional liability coverage to extend beyond regular auto or homeowners insurance.
🔹 Plan Details
- Plan Categories:
- Basic: Standard coverage for auto and home insurance.
- Premium: Additional options such as comprehensive coverage for high-value properties and vehicles.
- Basic: Standard coverage for auto and home insurance.
- Policy Terms and Conditions: Policies typically renew annually, with clear guidelines on premium increases and coverage renewal.
- Waiting Periods: No waiting periods for most policies, but property claims may take longer to process depending on the type of damage or incident.
- Coverage Limits: Varies based on policy and state, but typically ranges from $100,000 to $1 million in liability coverage.
- Exclusions and Restrictions: Excludes flood damage from homeowners policies, pre-existing conditions for health insurance, and intentional damage in auto insurance claims.
- Add-ons or Riders Available: Offers riders for higher liability limits, additional personal property coverage, and flood insurance options.
- Premium Payment Options: Premiums can be paid monthly, quarterly, or annually.
- Discounts Offered:
- Multi-policy discounts
- Safe driver discounts
- Home security discounts
- Bundling auto and home policies for savings.
- Multi-policy discounts
🔹 Application Process
- How to Apply: Applications can be completed online via the Grange Mutual Insurance website, through an agent, or over the phone.
- Time Required for Approval: Most policies are approved within 24-48 hours for standard coverage, but specialized business policies may take longer.
- Medical Exams (if any): Medical exams may be required for life insurance policies but not for other types of coverage.
- Online Quote Tools: Available for auto and homeowners insurance to get an instant quote.
- Pre-approval or Instant Policy Options: Instant auto insurance quotes are available online, with pre-approval for some policies.
🔹 Claims Process
- How to File a Claim: Claims can be filed online, via the Grange Mutual Insurance mobile app, or by contacting customer support.
- Time Taken to Settle Claims: Claims are generally settled within 5-15 business days, depending on the complexity.
- Required Documents for Claims:
- Claim form
- Proof of damage
- Police reports (for auto or theft claims)
- Claim form
- Claim Denial Reasons: Claims may be denied due to incomplete documentation, misrepresentation, or excluded perils.
- 24/7 Claim Support Availability: Customer support is available 24/7 via phone and online.
- Mobile App or Online Claim Tracking: Claims can be tracked through the Grange Mutual Insurance mobile app, allowing real-time updates.
🔹 Customer Support
- Contact Methods: Reach customer support via phone, email, or live chat.
- Office Hours: Monday to Friday, 8 AM to 6 PM CST.
- Mobile App Features: The app allows for claim filing, policy management, and quote generation.
- Local Agents or Offices Availability: Grange Mutual has local agents in multiple states, particularly in Ohio, Michigan, and Georgia.
- Multilingual Support: Available in Spanish and English.
🔹 Financials & Legal
- Underwriting Company: Grange Mutual Insurance Company underwrites the policies, ensuring the financial stability of claims.
- Regulatory Compliance: Grange Mutual complies with state insurance regulations and consumer protection laws.
- Licensing State-wise: Licensed in multiple U.S. states, with expansion in the Midwest and Southeast.
- Claim Payout Statistics: Claims are typically paid with an 89% payout ratio.
- Recent Legal Issues or Lawsuits: No major ongoing legal issues.
🔹 Technology and Innovation
- AI or Machine Learning Use: Uses automated systems for claims processing and fraud detection.
- Mobile App Rating and Features: The Grange Mutual mobile app has a 4.6/5 rating, praised for its user-friendly interface and claims tracking capabilities.
- Digital Policy Management: Fully paperless policy management available online.
- Telematics for Auto Insurance: Telematics available for auto insurance policies to track safe driving habits.
- Online Tools and Calculators: Offers premium calculators, coverage estimators, and online quotes.
🔹 Market Position and Competitors
- Market Share: Grange Mutual holds a significant regional share in the Midwest.
- Top Competitors: State Farm, Progressive, Allstate.
- Comparison with Leading Competitors: Grange Mutual offers more affordable rates compared to the larger insurers, but with fewer nationwide options.
- Unique Selling Points (USPs): Strong focus on regional expertise, customer care, and competitive pricing.
🔹 Reviews and Testimonials
- Real Customer Stories: Customers appreciate the quick service, affordable premiums, and friendly agents. Some complaints include slow response times during high volume claims.
- Complaints and Resolution Rate: Grange Mutual has a high resolution rate with 85% of complaints resolved within 30 days.
- Social Media Presence and Engagement: Active on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram, frequently engaging with clients and sharing insurance tips.


🔹 Final Evaluation
Pros:
- Affordable premiums with discount options.
- Reliable customer support and 24/7 claims assistance.
- Excellent mobile app for easy management of policies.
Cons:
- Limited state availability compared to nationwide competitors.
- Slow claims settlement for complex cases.
Who Should Consider This Company:
- Residents of Ohio, Michigan, and Georgia seeking affordable property and casualty insurance.
Who Might Want to Avoid It:
- Those looking for nationwide coverage or health insurance.
Expert Recommendations:
Grange Mutual is an excellent choice for regional clients seeking reliable and affordable coverage. Highly recommended for homeowners and business owners in the Midwest looking for a local insurer with a strong focus on customer satisfaction.